Matthew Phillion - Author
Welcome to the 

Indestructi-Blog

  • Home
  • Indestructi-Blog
  • About the Books
  • Purchase Signed Copies
  • Pro Game Master Sessions

10/30/2023

A look back

5 Comments

Read Now
 
Coming up on the ten-year anniversary of the first Indestructibles book and I keep thinking about perspectives that have evolved and how it'd be different if I wrote it now, especially because a few recent readers have said it feels like it was written today. 

A few of the characters weren't intentionally written to be ND, but definitely are - Emily for sure, Kate very likely, maybe Bedlam. Arguments could be made for others. 

In the years since the first edition came out, I've occasionally wondered if Jane is ace/demi. The book was marketed as YA but didn't fit with a lot of the prerequisite tropes, and there wasn't much romance involved. Not by design, just how the characters reacted to the world. 

Emily's pop culture obsession was intentionally evergreen so it wouldn't age out. She likes old nerdy stuff. Would change: she makes jokes a few times about a series I don't want to be associated with anymore, of course. But it feels weird to retroactively edit those out. 

(Speaking of, as the resident Whovian Em would have adored Jodie Whittaker's Doctor, but her favorite remains the 9th. She would have imprinted on Eccleston's feral energy.) 

I absolutely would have avoided the ship having an "AI" persona given what's happening now, but it's such a sci-fi trope I'm not too mad about it. I started working with AI researchers a few years after the book came out; I know so much more now. 

​More to follow... gotta step away for a bit but it's interesting doing a look back at one's own work as a writer. 

Share

5 Comments
Michael Kelley
10/31/2023 10:10:41 am

As a person who is perpetually out of touch all I can say is a slightly perplexed "wha?" What does North Dakota have to do with anything? I can make some vague guesses because of your reference to "ace" which I think, but am not sure, means asexual? And I am now curious as to which one of Emily's pop culture references are now not the best choice.

Reply
Matthew Phillion
10/31/2023 10:20:29 am

Yeah, being so wired in to everything I almost wish I wasn't, but seeing how books published today instead of ten years ago acknowledge themes like this I can't help thinking what a publisher would use for keywords for the books today. (The nice thing is the way they're written if you're not tied into online discourse, you can just read and enjoy them without needing any context at all!)

ND - neurodivergent, ace is asexual (particularly thinking of this because of the recent report that Gen Z wants fewer romantic relationships in their stories, which I find fascinating... there was pressure to make Jane have a love triangle or something when the book first came out an I'm like the girl is saving the planet, she has not the TIME, dudes!). For the pop culture reference, I thought Harry Potter was safe to include, but then JK got so toxic the past few years I wish I'd left the Hogwarts references out. The funny part about that was when I included the pop references my worry was "will anyone REMEMBER that movie or show?" to make it evergreen, not "I wonder if the author will alienate a huge swath of her readers so bad it'll impact LEGO sales of her characters." My running joke right now is "George Lucas better not mess things up, I have so many Star Wars references in there..."

Reply
Michael Kelley
10/31/2023 12:02:23 pm

Got it. I should have know ND. I have two friends whose sons are ND. And I didn't even think about Harry Potter. I read those along with my nephews when they first came out, but stopped after the original series and have only heard about some of Ms. Rowlings' nonsense peripherally.

It is funny sometimes I read about an author trying to be inclusive in their work and wonder why they bother. I am not offended by it just that I don't personally know anyone that is trans, or homosexual. I have one bi sexual friend but haven't seen her in person in several years and we don't discuss romantic issues. Then I remember that I am the outlier these days.

Matthew Phillion
10/31/2023 12:18:02 pm

Yeah, I need to be more inclusive because most of the folks in my life outside of my immediate family are part of groups who need more characters in stories like them. In a way I'm kind of happy about accidental inclusion in the Indestructibles - I didn't know we'd be having so much discussion about neurodivergence when I wrote it but a lot of folks have said they see themselves in Kate or Emily and I didn't do that on purpose - I was just writing characters like the people in my life.

I have tons of trans friends so I'm miffed I included a few Hogwarts jokes because they feel so hurt by her (it's kinda amazing how much good will she burned away when she was on top of the world!), but I hope folks understand that these books were written at the height of the HP zeitgeist. Heck, without HP, I don't get the publishing contract for a YA novel like this, so they're kind of inherently entwined in a way. I actually hope that rather than hold it against an older book, people get into the habit of just flipping to the copyright page. "Oh, this was written in 2014? We didn't know yet!"

Reply
Tasting Tiffany link
10/1/2024 10:50:10 am

I enjooyed reading your post

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    About the author

    Matthew Phillion is the author of the Indestructibles YA novel series, its spinoff Echo and the Sea, and the Dungeon Crawlers series of RPG-style novellas. 

    Archives

    November 2023
    October 2023
    June 2023
    December 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    September 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Indestructi-Blog
  • About the Books
  • Purchase Signed Copies
  • Pro Game Master Sessions